Skip to main content
Navigating New York's Mandatory Retirement Landscape: A Guide to the Secure Choice Savings Program for SMBs
Key Takeaways
  1. Mandatory Participation and Deadlines: Employers with at least 5 employees in NYC and 10 elsewhere must enroll staff within nine months post-launch, according to the law signed by Governor Kathy Hochul in 2021. Despite initially vague deadlines, progress was made in a January 2022 meeting, with enrollment specifics expected soon.
  2. Automatic Enrollment and Employee Options: Upon enrollment, employees contribute 3% of wages automatically, though they retain the option to opt-out. Employers are required to facilitate open enrollment annually, ensuring contributions remain portable and granting employees greater flexibility.
  3. IRA Limits and Tax Benefits: Employees can save up to annual Roth IRA limits ($7,000 under 50, $8,000 over 50 in 2024), enjoying tax-free growth and withdrawals post-retirement. This aspect of the Secure Choice Savings Program aligns with employee preferences for automatic payroll deduction plans, as evidenced by data showing 91% preference in similar programs across ten other states.
Introduction

Navigating New York’s Mandatory Retirement Landscape, Governor Kathy Hochul signed a groundbreaking law in October 2021, mandating New York businesses with 5 or more employees in NYC and 10 or more employees elsewhere to provide retirement options, introducing the Secure Choice Savings Program.

This legislation aims to address the retirement gap for approximately 4.3 million private-sector employees in New York, marking a significant step towards filling this void. This article breaks down crucial aspects of the program and how businesses can comply.

Overview of the Secure Choice Savings Program

Originally enacted in 2018, this automatic enrollment payroll deduction IRA retirement savings program aims to bolster retirement options for those without existing plans. As of 2023, program implementation details remain pending.

Mandatory Participation and Deadlines

Private-sector companies with at least 5 employees in NYC and 10 employees elsewhere must comply, enrolling employees within nine months of the program’s launch. While deadlines were initially vague, a January 2022 meeting indicated progress, and enrollment specifics are expected soon.

Alternatives for Businesses with Existing Plans

Businesses offering 401(k), 403(b), or pension plans are exempt from the Secure Choice mandate. Explore alternatives, such as 401(k) plans, with our helpful resources.

Automatic Enrollment and Employee Options

Once enrolled, employees contribute 3% of their wages automatically, but they can opt-out. Employers must facilitate open enrollment annually. Contributions are portable, enhancing employee flexibility.

Costs and Contributions

Employers face minimal administrative set-up fees, making Secure Choice an affordable option. The legislation includes a one-time $4 million investment, ensuring employers are not required to match employee contributions.

IRA Limits and Tax Benefits

Employees can save up to annual Roth IRA limits ($7,000 under 50, $8,000 over 50 in 2024), enjoying tax-free growth and tax-free withdrawals post-retirement.

National Landscape and Employee Preferences

New York isn’t alone in its efforts, with over ten states adopting similar programs. Data suggests 91% of employees prefer automatic payroll deduction plans, enhancing retirement savings.

Program Status and Updates

While the program was signed into law in 2021, specific details are pending as of January 2024. Employers should stay informed about developments and enrollment dates through the official Secure Choice Savings Program website.

Your New 401(k) Could be Fully Reimbursed See Your Secure Act 2.0 Savings Now
What Retirement Plan is Suitable for Your Business?

Business owners must understand if state laws require offering a retirement plan. States are implementing mandates due to the significant number of Americans underprepared for retirement. Consider whether a state-run plan or private retirement plan best serves your business and employees.

Conclusion: Benefits for Employers and Employees

Understanding the Secure Choice Savings Program is vital for businesses aiming to attract and retain talent. Whether through state-sponsored plans or private alternatives, offering retirement savings contributes to a mutually beneficial work environment. Click here for guidance on setup and options, exploring our team’s expertise.

Frequently asked questions (FAQs)
  1. What are the participation requirements and deadlines for New York’s Secure Choice Savings Program?
    Private-sector companies in New York with at least 5 employees in NYC and 10 employees elsewhere must comply with the program, enrolling employees within nine months of its launch. Despite initially vague deadlines, a January 2022 meeting hinted at progress, with enrollment specifics anticipated soon.
  2. What alternatives exist for businesses with existing retirement plans?
    Businesses offering 401(k), 403(b), or pension plans are exempt from the Secure Choice mandate. They can explore alternatives like 401(k) plans, benefiting from our helpful resources.
  3. How do the costs and contributions of the Secure Choice Savings Program impact employers and employees?
    Employers encounter minimal administrative setup fees, rendering Secure Choice an affordable option. Additionally, the legislation includes a one-time $4 million investment, alleviating the need for employers to match employee contributions.